ACL injury & reconstruction

ACL injury & reconstruction

A five-part guide to anterior cruciate ligament injury: what has torn, whether surgery is needed, the graft choices, the operation, and the nine-month road back to sport.

A torn anterior cruciate ligament is the injury that ends seasons. It happens in a moment, usually without anyone touching you, and it raises the same questions in everyone: what exactly has torn, do I need an operation, which graft, how long until I can play, and will I get arthritis.

This guide answers those questions in order, across five chapters. It is written to be read at your own pace, before or after your consultation, and it is honest about the numbers, including the ones that are not reassuring: how many people get back to their sport, and how often the ACL tears again.

Three things are worth saying at the start.

First, not every ACL tear needs surgery. The randomised trials are clear that a rehabilitation-first approach, with reconstruction for the knees that stay unstable, gives similar results to early surgery for many people. The decision depends on your knee, your sport and what you want from it, and that conversation comes before any date is set.

Second, the operation is the shorter part. A reconstruction takes about an hour and is usually a day procedure. The recovery takes nine months to a year, and what you do in those months decides the result more than anything that happens in theatre.

Third, the graft choice is made for you, not by habit. Hamstring, patellar tendon, quadriceps tendon and donor tendon each have a track record, and the chapter on the operation sets out what the evidence shows about each, including the donor-tendon grafts this practice uses often.

Start with the first chapter below, or jump to the one that matches where you are.

In this series

Related pages

From the Journal Club

All entries →

Read or print this guide

The complete acl injury & reconstruction guide is available as a PDF, useful if you would like to print it and read it at home. Available in English; other languages are being prepared.

Download PDF

Common questions

Do I need a referral to see Dr Broadhead about an ACL injury?

Yes. A valid referral from your GP, sports physician or another specialist is required for all appointments. You can then book online or call (02) 9052 1883, Monday to Friday.

Does every ACL tear need surgery?

No. Many people, particularly those who do not play pivoting sport, manage well with rehabilitation alone, and the randomised trials show that a rehabilitation-first approach with surgery for those whose knees stay unstable gives similar results at two and five years. Surgery is recommended for the knee that keeps giving way, for the athlete returning to pivoting sport, and where a repairable meniscal tear needs a stable knee to heal.

How long after an ACL reconstruction can I play sport?

Running from about three months if the knee passes its tests. Pivoting sport not before nine months, and only after a full return-to-sport test. Each month of waiting up to nine months roughly halves the re-injury rate, and that is the reason for the number.

Where does Dr Broadhead do ACL reconstructions?

In Sydney from the North Sydney rooms, and in Coffs Harbour, with surgery at the hospital most appropriate to each patient. ACL reconstruction is not performed at Camperdown. Most isolated reconstructions are day procedures.

What is the risk of tearing the ACL again?

Higher than most people expect, especially in the young: about one in four athletes under 25 who return to sport sustain a further ACL injury to either knee. Waiting the full nine months, passing return-to-sport testing, and keeping up a structured warm-up program are the three things that lower it.

Sources

  1. Ardern CL et al. Fifty-five per cent return to competitive sport following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis. Br J Sports Med 2014;48:1543–52
  2. Grindem H et al. Simple decision rules can reduce reinjury risk by 84% after ACL reconstruction: the Delaware-Oslo ACL cohort study. Br J Sports Med 2016;50:804–8
  3. Wiggins AJ et al. Risk of secondary injury in younger athletes after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med 2016;44:1861–76
  4. OrthoInfo (AAOS), Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) Injuries
CallBookEmail